On the Associated Press first teams from 1940 through 2025, 122 players who were never drafted have made the first team - 212 selections between them, 23 of them now in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. That is the whole answer to "which undrafted players made first-team All-Pro," and this page is the full list, decade by decade, with every name, team and season checked against Pro-Football-Reference's All-Pro pages and each player's own page. Two things stand out before you reach a single name. The first is how heavily the modern list tilts toward kickers, punters, long snappers and return men: 18 of the 19 undrafted first-teamers whose first selection came in the 2020s are specialists. The second is how many of the position players are not just All-Pros but Canton inductees, from Marion Motley and Emlen Tunnell to John Randle, Kurt Warner and Antonio Gates - a stranger group than the best undrafted players in NFL history usually gets credit for.

What Counts as an Undrafted First-Team All-Pro
Two rules, both strict. First, "first-team All-Pro" means the Associated Press first team as listed on Pro-Football-Reference's All-Pro page for each season from 1940 through 2025. Second-team picks do not count, and neither do the Pro Football Writers, Sporting News or PFF teams. Second, "undrafted" means no team spent a pick of any kind on the player - not in the NFL draft, not in the AFL draft of the 1960s, and not in a supplemental draft. That last clause removes some famous names. Reggie White, Steve Young and Gary Zimmerman were all taken in the 1984 supplemental draft, Cris Carter in 1987, Rob Moore in 1990, Jamal Williams in 1998 and Josh Gordon in 2012; Jim Otto and Jan Stenerud were AFL draft picks. All of them show up on casual "undrafted" lists, and none of them belongs on this one.
One more scope note. The AP also named All-AFL teams in the 1960s and All-AAFC teams in the late 1940s, and PFR folds those into a player's career total, which is why Willie Brown's page says five first-team selections while only two of them - 1971 and 1973, after the merger - appear below. This is the NFL list.
The Numbers: 122 Players, 212 Selections, 23 Hall of Famers
Fifty of the 122 were named more than once, and 24 made the first team three or more times. The leader is John Randle with six straight selections from 1993 through 1998; Riley Matheson, Mick Tingelhoff, Larry Little and Justin Tucker have five each. Seventy of the 122 made it as position players and 52 as specialists, but the balance has flipped over time. Every one of the 26 undrafted first-teamers from 1940 through the 1960s was a position player; of the 25 whose first selection came from 2016 on, 21 were kickers, punters, long snappers, returners or special-teams players. Adam Vinatieri is the only specialist among the 23 Hall of Famers.
The 1940s: Before and Just After the First Draft
Two of the greatest players of the era were never drafted for the simplest reason: the first NFL draft was held in 1936, and they were already in the league. Mel Hein joined the Giants in 1931 and Don Hutson the Packers in 1935. PFR credits Hein with five first-team selections (1934, 1935, 1938, 1939 and 1940) and the 1938 Carr Trophy as the league's most valuable player, and Hutson with eight first teams running from 1938 through 1945, two Carr Trophies and three championships. They are set apart here because nobody passed on them.
The nine undrafted first-teamers from the draft era's first decade were, by position: Detroit guard Socko Wiethe (1940); Washington tackle Willie Wilkin (1941, 1942); Bears end George Wilson (1942); Rams guard Riley Matheson, first team in 1942, 1944, 1945, 1946 and 1947, still tied for the second-most selections by any undrafted player; Giants fullback Bill Paschal (1944); Detroit guard Bill Radovich (1945); Giants tackle Frank Cope (1945); Washington halfback Steve Bagarus (1945); and Packers fullback Ted Fritsch (1946). Matheson's five teams came when the AP named only eleven first-teamers for the whole league (1940 through 1945), then seven in 1946 and six in 1947.
The 1950s: Paul Brown's Undrafted Hall of Famers
When the Browns came over from the AAFC in 1950, they brought three undrafted future Hall of Famers who would all make the AP first team in the NFL - fullback Marion Motley (1950), middle guard Bill Willis (1951, 1952, 1953) and center Frank Gatski (1952, 1953, 1955) - and picked up a fourth that year in defensive end Len Ford (1951 through 1954), who had spent two AAFC seasons with the Los Angeles Dons. Lou Groza, "The Toe," was a fifth - his four first teams from 1952 through 1955 came as a tackle, not a kicker. Across town in New York, Emlen Tunnell was first team four times (1951, 1952, 1955, 1956) on his way to nine Pro Bowls, and 49ers fullback Joe Perry, undrafted out of Compton junior college, made it in 1953 and 1954 and was the UPI's 1954 MVP.
The three undrafted defensive backs of the decade all reached Canton. Dick "Night Train" Lane intercepted 14 passes as a Rams rookie in 1952, finished with 68, and was first team in 1956, 1961 and 1962; Pittsburgh's Jack Butler made it three straight years from 1957 through 1959. Rounding out the decade's twelve: Rams linebacker Tank Younger (1951), Rams end Bob Boyd (1954) and Colts tackle Gene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb (1958, 1959), who never played college football. If you are measuring the era's secondaries, the greatest cornerbacks in NFL history includes Lane.
The 1960s: Willie Wood, Mick Tingelhoff and the Thin Years
Only five undrafted players made the AP's NFL first team in the 1960s, partly because the AFL was signing the same talent pool. Two are Hall of Famers. Packers safety Willie Wood, undrafted out of USC in 1960, was first team four straight years from 1964 through 1967 with 48 career interceptions and five NFL titles. Vikings center Mick Tingelhoff made it in 1964, 1965, 1966, 1968 and 1969, and started all 240 games of his career. The others: Bears safety Rosey Taylor (1963), Cowboys cornerback Cornell Green (1966, 1967) and Lions flanker Pat Studstill (1966). Willie Brown's AP All-AFL first teams in 1964, 1968 and 1969, and Rich Jackson's in 1968 and 1969, belong to the other league's list.
The 1970s: Dolphins, Cowboys and Steelers
The decade produced 16 undrafted first-teamers and seven Hall of Famers. Miami's early-seventies line was built on two of them: guard Larry Little, first team every year from 1971 through 1975, and center Jim Langer (1974, 1975, 1977), both undrafted and both in Canton, a pairing worth measuring against the greatest offensive linemen in NFL history. The Cowboys found receiver Drew Pearson (1974, 1976, 1977) out of Tulsa and safety Cliff Harris (1976, 1977, 1978) out of Ouachita Baptist; the Steelers found strong safety Donnie Shell (1979, 1980, 1982) at South Carolina State. Add Raiders cornerback Willie Brown (1971, 1973) and Chiefs cornerback Emmitt Thomas (1974) and that is the seven.
The first undrafted specialists arrived here, two of them born overseas: Dolphins kicker Garo Yepremian from Larnaca, Cyprus (1971, 1973), Oilers kicker Toni Fritsch from Vienna (1979) and Jets kicker Pat Leahy (1978), plus Giants punter Dave Jennings (1979, 1980). The rest of the decade: Broncos end Rich Jackson (1970), Bills cornerback Robert James (1973, 1974), Bills safety Tony Greene (1974), Falcons cornerback Rolland Lawrence (1977) and Oilers safety Mike Reinfeldt (1979).

The 1980s: Cherry, Jacoby, Walls and the Kickers
No Hall of Famers among the decade's 15, but a lot of very good football. Chiefs safety Deron Cherry (1984, 1986, 1988) retired with 50 interceptions and six Pro Bowls. Washington's Joe Jacoby, a 6-foot-7 tackle out of Louisville, anchored the Hogs to first teams in 1983 and 1984 and three Super Bowl rings. Dallas cornerback Everson Walls was first team in 1983 and finished with 57 interceptions; Browns cornerback Frank Minnifield made it in 1988; Bears center Jay Hilgenberg (1988, 1989) went to seven Pro Bowls. Also on the list: Chiefs returner J.T. Smith (1980), Falcons receiver Alfred Jenkins (1981), Broncos linebacker Bob Swenson (1981), Washington safety Mark Murphy (1983) and Seahawks nose tackle Joe Nash (1984).
Five kickers and punters: Seahawks kicker Norm Johnson (1984), Chiefs kicker Nick Lowery (1985, 1990), Giants punter Sean Landeta (1986, 1989, 1990), Bills kicker Scott Norwood (1988) and 49ers kicker Mike Cofer (1989).
The 1990s: John Randle and Kurt Warner
Randle is the headline. Signed by Minnesota out of Texas A&M-Kingsville in 1990, he was first team six years running from 1993 through 1998, retired with 137.5 sacks and is in the Hall of Fame. Kurt Warner's two first teams (1999, 2001) came with his two AP MVP awards in St. Louis, and his route from Northern Iowa through the Arena League is the reason the best undrafted quarterbacks in NFL history starts with him. The decade's third Hall of Famer is Sam Mills, the 5-foot-9 Montclair State linebacker who made the first team at 37 with Carolina in 1996. Up front, Bills center Kent Hull (1990, 1991) and Cowboys guard Nate Newton (1994, 1995) were both first team twice.
The other nine are all kickers and punters, the first decade in which specialists outnumbered position players: Raiders punter Jeff Gossett (1991), Cardinals punter Rich Camarillo (1992), Chargers kicker John Carney (1994), Sydney-born Chargers punter Darren Bennett (1995), Colts kicker Cary Blanchard (1996), Washington punter Matt Turk (1996), Jaguars punter Bryan Barker (1997), Cowboys kicker Richie Cunningham (1997) and Dolphins kicker Olindo Mare (1999).
The 2000s: Gates, Holmes, Harrison and Welker
Seventeen players, and the best run of undrafted position players since the fifties. Antonio Gates, out of Kent State, was first team at tight end in 2004, 2005 and 2006 and finished with 116 touchdown catches and a Hall of Fame jacket. Priest Holmes made it three straight years for Kansas City (2001 through 2003), won the 2002 AP Offensive Player of the Year and scored 27 rushing touchdowns in 2003. James Harrison, another Kent State product, was first team in 2008 and 2010 and the 2008 AP Defensive Player of the Year. Wes Welker (2009, 2011) caught 903 passes. Jeff Saturday (2005, 2007) and Brian Waters (2004, 2005) each went to six Pro Bowls on the interior line, and fullbacks Mack Strong (2005) and Leonard Weaver (2009) made it too.
Adam Vinatieri was first team in 2002, 2004 and 2014, won four Super Bowls and retired as the NFL's all-time scoring leader with 2,673 points; he is the lone specialist in Canton. The others: kicker David Akers (2001 with Philadelphia, 2011 with San Francisco), Colts kicker Mike Vanderjagt (2003), Bills punter Brian Moorman (2005, 2006), Bears kicker Robbie Gould (2006), Titans kicker Rob Bironas (2007), and three return men - Saints returner Michael Lewis, who never played college football and piled up 2,647 all-purpose yards in 2002; Lions returner Eddie Drummond, who scored four return touchdowns in 2004; and Browns returner Josh Cribbs (2009), the third Kent State alum on this page.
The 2010s: Tucker, Hekker and Jason Peters
Justin Tucker's five first teams (2013, 2016, 2018, 2019, 2021) are the most by any undrafted player since Randle, and Johnny Hekker's four as a Rams punter (2013, 2015, 2016, 2017) are next. Among position players, Jason Peters (2011, 2013) made nine Pro Bowls at tackle after signing with Buffalo out of Arkansas in 2004, Arian Foster ran for 1,616 yards and 16 touchdowns for Houston's 2010 first team, and Vonta Leach was the AP's fullback three straight years (2010 through 2012). The decade's other position players: Dolphins pass rusher Cameron Wake (2012), fullbacks Mike Tolbert (2013, 2015) and John Kuhn (2014), Broncos cornerback Chris Harris Jr. (2016), Giants defensive tackle Damon Harrison (2016) and Panthers guard Andrew Norwell (2017). Specialists: Ravens kicker Billy Cundiff (2010), Chargers special-teamer Adrian Phillips (2018), Titans punter Brett Kern (2019) and Saints returner Deonte Harty (2019).
The 2020s: A List Owned by Specialists
Nineteen undrafted players earned their first selection between the 2020 and 2025 teams, and 18 of them were specialists. Ravens fullback Patrick Ricard (2024) is the only position player. On PFR's All-Pro pages the AP first team has carried a dedicated special-teams slot since 2016 and a long-snapper slot since 2020, and undrafted players have claimed both repeatedly: special-teamers George Odum (2020), J.T. Gray (2021), Jeremy Reaves (2022), Brenden Schooler (2024) and Devon Key (2025), and long snappers Morgan Cox (2020), Luke Rhodes (2021), Andrew DePaola (2022, 2024) and Ross Matiscik (2023, 2025). Punters AJ Cole III (2021, 2023), Tommy Townsend (2022) and Jack Fox (2024), kickers Brandon Aubrey (2023) and Chris Boswell (2024), and returners Gunner Olszewski (2020), Keisean Nixon (2022, 2023), Rashid Shaheed (2023) and KaVontae Turpin (2024) complete the decade so far.

Why the Undrafted Keep Making First Team
Three patterns run through all 122 names. Small schools: Ouachita Baptist, Montclair State, Texas A&M-Kingsville, South Dakota State, Carson-Newman, Bemidji State and three different Kent State alumni, players whose tape nobody graded. Positions that do not match the name: Lou Groza, remembered as a kicker, made all four of his first teams as a tackle, and Tank Younger, a fullback, made his at linebacker. And the positions the draft undervalues most: nearly the entire post-2016 wave is kickers, punters, snappers and return men, because teams still spend their picks elsewhere and sort those jobs out in training camp. The misses are the mirror image of the biggest busts in NFL draft history: the same scouting machine, wrong in the other direction. It also makes these careers the hardest to guess from a team list in Career Path, and the best trivia answers in Who Am I?.
Related Reading
- The Best Undrafted NFL Players of All Time, Ranked
- The Best Undrafted Quarterbacks in NFL History
- The Best NFL Safeties of All Time, From Krause to Ed Reed
- The NFL MVP Award: Every Multiple Winner in History
An undrafted All-Pro's team list is the best puzzle in football: a tryout camp, a cut, a second franchise, then five straight first teams. Trace a mystery player's journey in our daily Career Path quiz, or try today's Gridiron Grid.