← Back to blog

The Greatest NFL Playoff Games of All Time

By Bryan Ng11 min read
playoffsmomentshistory

A championship game in 1958 went to sudden death and no NFL title had ever been decided that way before. Nine years later two teams played for a championship at fifteen degrees below zero and it was settled with thirteen seconds on the clock. In 1972 a team faced fourth and ten from its own forty with twenty-two seconds left and no timeouts, and won. These are the games that get replayed every January with the same commentary, and the reason is always the same: the margin was one play, and everybody watching knew it at the time. Here are the greatest playoff games in the sport's history, with what actually happened in each.

Stylized illustration for The Greatest NFL Playoff Games of All Time
Play while you readRoll CallName everyone who touched the ball in one playoff game

What Makes a Playoff Game Great

Three things, and a game needs at least two of them.

The first is that the result was in doubt in the final minute. A blowout can be historically important without being a great game, and the entries below are almost all decided on a final drive, a final play or in an extra period.

The second is consequence. A wild-card game and a championship game are not equal, and a game that ended a dynasty or started one carries weight that a good afternoon in January does not.

The third is that something happened in it that had not happened before. The 1958 title game invented the idea that a championship could go to sudden death. The 1972 divisional round produced a play that people still argue about the legality of. Novelty is what separates the games that get named from the games that get remembered.

1958 NFL Championship: Colts 23, Giants 17

The first NFL championship ever decided in overtime, and the game most often credited with turning professional football into a national sport.

Baltimore beat the Giants at Yankee Stadium in front of 64,185 people, and the sudden-death finish was genuinely novel - no title game had gone past regulation before. It was fifty-nine years before another league championship would be decided the same way.

Its importance is mostly external to the football. This was the game that proved the sport worked on television, and much of the money and attention that followed traces back to that afternoon.

1967 NFL Championship: Packers 21, Cowboys 17 - the Ice Bowl

Played at Lambeau Field on December 31 at a game-time temperature of about fifteen degrees below zero, with an average wind chill around forty-eight below.

Those numbers are not color, they are the game. Players lost feeling in their hands in the first quarter and the field froze solid underneath them. Green Bay won it with thirteen seconds remaining, on a play from a yard out that either works or ends the season with no time to try anything else.

It was the third consecutive championship for that Green Bay team, the only three-peat in the sport's history, covered in the greatest NFL dynasties of all time. Two weeks later they won Super Bowl II.

1972 AFC Divisional: Steelers 13, Raiders 7 - the Immaculate Reception

Fourth and ten from their own forty-yard line, twenty-two seconds remaining, no timeouts, trailing 7-6.

Terry Bradshaw threw toward a running back, the ball came off a collision, and Franco Harris caught it at his shoe tops and ran it in. The extra point made it 13-7.

The legality of the play was disputed at the time under the rules then in force and has been argued about ever since, which is part of why it endures. It is also the moment the Pittsburgh dynasty that would win four Super Bowls announced itself.

Editorial illustration: The Greatest NFL Playoff Games of All Time

1981 NFC Championship: 49ers 28, Cowboys 27 - the Catch

Third and three from the Dallas six-yard line with 58 seconds left.

Joe Montana threw high toward the back of the end zone and Dwight Clark caught it at full stretch. San Francisco went on to win their first Super Bowl two weeks later, the first of five in a fourteen-year run.

What makes this one more than a great finish is what it ended. Dallas had been the NFC's standing power for a decade. This was the afternoon the balance moved, and it stayed moved for fifteen years.

1981 AFC Divisional: Chargers 41, Dolphins 38 - the Epic in Miami

January 2, 1982, in overtime, and the single most physically punishing game anybody has recorded.

Kellen Winslow caught 13 passes for 166 yards and a touchdown, blocked a field goal, and was carried off the field by teammates at the end because he could not walk. It is the performance that made the modern tight end position conceivable, and it is covered in full in the greatest tight ends in NFL history.

Seventy-nine points, an overtime period, and a game played in heat and humidity that left both rosters emptied out by the end of it. Neither team reached the Super Bowl.

1992 AFC Wild Card: Bills 41, Oilers 38 - the Comeback

Down 35-3, with a backup quarterback, at home on January 3, 1993.

Buffalo erased a 32-point deficit, which remains the largest comeback in postseason history, and won it in overtime. They cut it from 32 points to four inside seven minutes. The full account is in the greatest comebacks in NFL history.

Frank Reich, starting in place of an injured Jim Kelly, is the answer to one of the better trivia questions in the sport.

1999 AFC Wild Card: Titans 22, Bills 16 - the Music City Miracle

Buffalo took a 16-15 lead on a field goal with sixteen seconds remaining. That is normally the end of a playoff game.

On the ensuing kickoff, Tennessee's tight end Frank Wycheck threw a lateral across the field to Kevin Dyson, who ran 75 yards for the winning touchdown. Whether the pass travelled forward was reviewed, upheld, and has been argued about for a quarter of a century.

Tennessee went to the Super Bowl that year and lost it by a yard, which makes this the first half of the most frustrating postseason run any franchise has had.

2013 AFC Wild Card: Colts 45, Chiefs 44

Down 38-10, and won by one point without the safety net of overtime.

It is the second largest comeback in NFL playoff history, and the strangest thing about it is that Kansas City never stopped scoring. Forty-four points would win almost any playoff game ever played. It did not win this one.

Super Bowl XLII: Giants 17, Patriots 14

A 12-point underdog beating a 16-0 team in the last game of the year, on a touchdown with 35 seconds left.

It is the most consequential upset in modern Super Bowl history and the reason a perfect season still belongs to a team from 1972. The full version sits in the biggest Super Bowl upsets in NFL history.

Super Bowl LI: Patriots 34, Falcons 28

Down 28-3 midway through the third quarter, and the first Super Bowl ever to reach overtime.

New England won the coin toss, took the ball and scored a touchdown on the opening possession of the extra period, which meant Atlanta never got it back. It is the largest comeback in Super Bowl history and the only league championship decided in overtime since 1958.

2017 NFC Divisional: Vikings 29, Saints 24 - the Minneapolis Miracle

A playoff game that ended on a walk-off touchdown as the clock hit zero, which is not something the postseason had produced before.

New Orleans had taken the lead inside the final half-minute. Minnesota needed a chunk of yardage to attempt a field goal, got the completion, and the defender missed the tackle, which turned a sideline catch into a walk-off touchdown as the clock hit zero.

The following season the same quarterback matchup produced another overtime finish, which is the kind of symmetry these things occasionally have.

Closing illustration for The Greatest NFL Playoff Games of All Time

What the List Has in Common

Look at the eleven games and the pattern is almost uncomfortably tidy.

Nine of them were decided in the final minute or in overtime. That is not a selection bias so much as a definition: a playoff game becomes great when it stays undecided long enough that both teams have to keep making decisions under a shrinking clock, and almost nothing that is settled by the third quarter survives in memory.

The second commonality is that most of them turned on a play that should not have worked. A fourth-and-ten heave that deflected. A lateral on a kickoff. A pass thrown high because the receiver was covered. Coaches do not design the endings of these games; the endings are what happens when a designed play breaks and somebody improvises correctly with a season on the line.

And the third is that the losing team is almost always the better one. Miami in 1981, Dallas in 1981, Oakland in 1972, New England in 2008 and Atlanta in 2017 were all at least as good as the teams that beat them across a full season. The postseason is a sampling error with a trophy attached, which is the entire reason it is worth watching.

The Franchises That Keep Turning Up

Read the eleven entries again and notice who is in them repeatedly, because it is not the franchises with the most trophies.

Buffalo appears three times, and lost two of the three. They produced the largest comeback in postseason history, were on the wrong end of the Music City Miracle seven years later, and lost Super Bowl XXV on a kick in the closing seconds. No franchise has contributed more to the sport's list of unforgettable January afternoons and finished with less.

Pittsburgh, New England and Green Bay each appear in games that either launched or ended an era, which is the more ordinary pattern: great teams play in great games because they are still playing in January every year, and the sheer number of appearances eventually produces a classic.

The instructive case is the 1981 Chargers and Dolphins, neither of whom reached the Super Bowl that season and one of whom did not reach one for another twenty years. The best game on this page by any measure of drama had no bearing on a championship at all, which is worth remembering when anybody argues that these things only matter if a trophy follows.

The Games That Nearly Made It

A few that belong in the conversation and fell just outside.

Super Bowl XXXIV, which ended with a tackle one yard short of the goal line on the final play - the same franchise that won the Music City Miracle three weeks earlier. It ranks fifth among the greatest Super Bowls of all time.

The 1982 AFC Championship, and the 1981 divisional round the week before it, which were both played by teams who had already used everything they had.

Super Bowl XXV, decided by a field goal attempt in the closing seconds that went wide right, and the only one of Buffalo's four Super Bowl defeats that a single play would have reversed.

The 2021 AFC Divisional round, in which the lead changed hands repeatedly inside the final two minutes of regulation before the game went to overtime, and the losing team never touched the ball there.

Related Reading


Playoff classics are the trivia everybody thinks they know, right up until somebody asks for the score. Name everyone who touched the ball in one playoff game in our daily Roll Call, or spot the made-up fact in Two Truths and a Lie.

More balls to juggle?

2026 sacked.gg  •  About •  Blog •  FAQ •  How to Play •  Contact •  Privacy •  Terms

sacked.gg is an unofficial fan project, not affiliated with, endorsed by, or licensed by the NFL, the NFLPA, or any of their teams. Player names and statistics are historical public record, used for informational and entertainment purposes only. Simulated games, results, and stat lines are fictional.